Effect of Plant Extracts Against Bipolaris oryzae of Rice under In vitro Conditions

Research Article
Effect of Plant Extracts Against Bipolaris oryzae of Rice under In vitro Conditions

Md. Farid Ahmed, K. M. Khalequzzaman, Md. Nazrul Islam, M. K. Anam and M. Tahasinul Islam

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2002, 5(4), 442-445.

Abstract

Twelve seed samples of rice were tested and all were found infected by Bipolaris oryzae the cause of brown spot disease. Highest (5.5%) and lowest (1.5%) incidence was found in sample of Bhabokhali and Mahozompur, respectively. Four plant extracts viz. biskatali (Polygonum hydropiper), onion (Allium cepa), garlic (Allium sativum) and neem (Azadirachta indica) were evaluated against Bipolaris oryzae. Among the plant extracts, neem and garlic were the most effective against Bipolaris oryzae at 1:1 dilution. All other plant extracts were also effective against Bipolaris oryzae at higher concentrations.

ASCI-ID: 1-2342

Cited References Fulltext

Similar Articles


In vitro Effect of Garlic Extract and Metronidazole Against Neoparamoeba pemaquidensis, Page 1987 and Isolated Amoebae from Atlantic Salmon

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2008, 11(1), 41-47.

Combined Supplementation of Soy and Garlic modulate Biochemical Parameters of 7,12-dimethylbenz[α]anthracene Induced Mammary Cancer in Female Albino Rats

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2007, 10(14), 2308-2313.

Evaluating Yield Quality and Quantity of Garlic as Affected by Different Farming Systems and Garlic Clones

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2007, 10(13), 2219-2224.

Effects of Organic Manures and Carbofuran on Nematodes Associated with Garlic (Allium sativum L.)

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2001, 4(3), 319-320.

Dry Matter Accumulation and Partitioning and Growth of Garlic as Influenced by Land Configuration and Cultivars

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2002, 5(10), 1028-1031.

Effects of Some Seasonal Vegetables and Fruits on the Growth of Bacteria

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2006, 9(8), 1547-1551.

Effect of Garlic along with Lead Acetate Administration on Lead Burden of Some Tissues in Mice

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2007, 10(16), 2772-2774.

Investigation the Growth, Yield and Yield Components of Rice Varieties in Rotation with Garlic, Faba Bean, Lettuce, Pea and Fallow in North of Iran

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2007, 10(16), 2688-2693.

Effect of Dietary Garlic on Immune Response of Broiler Chicks to Live Newcastle Disease Vaccine

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2008, 11(14), 1848-1851.

Antibacterial Effect of Garlic (Allium sativum L.) on Staphylococcus aureus

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2006, 9(8), 1577-1579.

In vivo Antimicrobial Potentials of Garlic against Clostridium perfringens and Its Promotant Effects on Performance of Broiler Chickens

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2013, 16(24), 1978-1984.

Effect of Benomyl Treated Garlic on Growth and Sporulation of Pythium aphanidermatum and Achlya americana

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2006, 9(5), 898-903.

Plant Regeneration and Floral Bud Formation from Intact Floral Parts of African Violet (Saintpaulia ionantha H. Wendl.) Cultured in vitro

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2008, 11(7), 1055-1058.

Growth Optimization and Organogenesis of Gerbera jamesonii Bolus ex. Hook f. in vitro

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2008, 11(11), 1449-1454.

Somatic Embryogenesis from Leaf Explants of Gladiolus anatolicus (Boiss.) Stapf

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2007, 10(8), 1190-1194.

Micro-Propagation Efficiency in Banana (Musa sp.) under Different Immersion Systems

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2007, 10(5), 726-733.

Effect of Nitric Oxide on Ram Sperm Motility In vitro

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2007, 10(14), 2374-2378.

In vitro Studies on Physiology of Fungi Isolated from Stem pieces of Cuscuta in Pakistan

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 1999, 2(3), 993-995.

An Efficient and Economical Method of Mass Multiplication of Virus and Disease Free Banana Using Plant Tissue Culture Techniques

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2001, 4(5), 562-563.

Micropropagation of Annona squamosa L. Using Nodal Explants

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2002, 5(1), 43-46.

Studies on Moisture Content, Biomass Yield (Crude Plant Extract) and Alkaloid Estimation of In vitro and Field Grown Plants of Rauvolfia serpentina

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2002, 5(4), 416-418.

In vitro Clonal Propagation of Sugarcane (Saccharum officinarum) Variety Isd 31

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2002, 5(6), 659-661.

Effects of Various Growth Regulators on Callus Formation and Regeneration in Brassica napus Cv. Oscar

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2002, 5(6), 693-695.

Rapid Clonal Propagation of Tamarindus indica (L) Using Explants from Adult Trees

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2003, 6(18), 1591-1592.

Separation of Thornless Rose Chimeras into Their (Rosa sp.) Consistent Genotypes in vitro

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2003, 6(19), 1644-1648.

Studies on the Rapid Clonal Propagation of Saccharum officinarum

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2003, 6(22), 1876-1879.

Assessment of in vitro activity of Peganum harmala Extract on Plasmodium falciparum Growth Compared with Chloroquine

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2006, 9(2), 214-216.

Study of Sugar Beet Cyst Nematode Life Cycle Using Plant Tissue Culture Method

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2007, 10(17), 2910-2914.

Effects of Different Concentrations of 2,4-D and BAP on Somatic Embryogenesis Induction in Saffron (Crocus sativus L.)

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2007, 10(21), 3927-3930.

Clonal Propagation of Mentha arvensis L. Through Nodal Explant

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2006, 9(8), 1416-1419.

Chemical Composition and In Vitro Gas Production of Silage from Guinea Grass, Cassava Peel and Cashew Apple Waste at Different Periods of Ensilage

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2013, 16(23), 1801-1805.

Effect of Curcuma zedoaria, Curcuma mangga and Cuminum cyminum on Rumen Ecology and Pb Profile in the Rumen of Mastitis Dairy Cows (in vitro)

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2015, 18(3), 146-148.

In vitro Production of Cormlets in Gladiolus

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2000, 3(5), 819-821.

In vitro Antibacterial Principles of Extracts and Two Flavonoids from Clerodendrum indicum Linn

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2000, 3(10), 1769-1771.

Evaluation of Different Explant Sources and Growth Regulators on Callus Culture and Regeneration in Strawberry (Fragaria ananassa)

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2000, 3(12), 2249-2250.

Rapid in vitro Clonal Propagation of Lavendula officinalis chaix a Multipurpose Plant of Industrial Importance

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2006, 9(3), 514-518.

Effect of Partial Substitution of Ration’s Soybean Meal by Biologically Treated Feathers on Rumen Fermentation Characteristics (in vitro)

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2018, 21(3), 110-118.

Effect of Caraway, Fennel and Melissa addition on in vitro Rumen Fermentation and Gas Production

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2019, 22(2), 67-72.

Effect of Neem (Azadirachta indica) on the Root-knot (Meloidogyne javanica) of Sweet gourd

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2000, 3(11), 1853-1854.

Effect of Carbon, Nitrogen and Soil Organic amendments Against Phytophthora capsici

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2000, 3(11), 1899-1900.

Oviposition Deterrence and Other Biological Influences of Aqueous Leaves Extracts of Neem, Colocasia and Their Mixtures Alone or Combined with Gamma Radiation to Reduce the Risk of the Potato Tubermoth,Phthorimaea operculella (Zeller)

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2002, 5(9), 911-914.

Effects of a Commercial Neem Insecticide ((Neem AzalTM-T/S) on Early and Late Developmental Stages of the Beet Armyworm, Spodoptera exiqua (Hubner) (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae)

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2005, 8(4), 520-526.

Effects of Neem Leaf Dust and a Commercial Formulation of a Neem Compound on the Longevity, Fecundity and Ovarian Development of the Melon Fly, Bactrocera cucurbitae (Coquillett) and the Oriental Fruit Fly, Bactrocera dorsalis (Hendel) (Diptera: Tephritidae)

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2007, 10(20), 3656-3661.

In Vitro Antifungal Activity of Neem Products Against Phytophthora Infestans

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2000, 3(5), 824-828.

Duration of Developmental Stages of Callosobruchus chinensis L. (Coleoptera:Bruchidae) on Azuki Bean and the Effects of Neem and Sesame Oils at Different Stages of Their Development

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2003, 6(10), 932-935.

Inhibitory Effect of Aqueous and Ethanolic Extracts of Neem Parts on Fungal Rot Disease of Solanum tuberosum

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2019, 22(5), 206-213.

Identification of the Causal Agent of Leaf Spot of Betelnut and in vitro Evaluation of Fungicides and Plant Extracts Against it

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2004, 7(10), 1758-1761.

Antifungal Activity of Some Extracts Against Some Plant Pathogenic Fungi

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2005, 8(3), 413-417.

Implementation of Bio-Fungicides and Seed Treatment in Organic Rice cv. KDML 105 Farming

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2009, 12(16), 1119-1126.

In vitro Antiplasmodial and Antibacterial Activities of Canthium multiflorum Schum and Thonn (Rubiacea) Extracts

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2009, 12(12), 919-923.

Estimation of Combining Ability for Yield and Yield Components in Rice(Oryza sativa L.) Cultivars Using Diallel Cross

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2008, 11(9), 1278-1281.

An Assessment of Wx Microsatellite Allele, Alkali Degradation and Differentiation of Chloroplast DNA in Traditional Black Rice (Oryza sativa L.) From Thailand and Lao PDR

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2007, 10(2), 261-266.

Effect of Zinc Application on Rice Yield under Wheat Rice System

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2007, 10(2), 235-239.

Agronomic and Quality Characteristics of High-Yielding Rice Lines

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2007, 10(1), 142-144.

Response of Rice Cultivars to Rates of Nitrogen and Potassium Application in Field and Pot Conditions

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2007, 10(9), 1430-1437.

Effects of N and K Applications on Agronomic Characteristics of Two Iranian and Landrace Rice (Oryza sativa L.) Cultivars

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2007, 10(6), 880-886.

Identification of Variant Transcripts of Waxy Gene in Non-glutinous Rice (O. sativa L.) With Different Amylose Content

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2007, 10(15), 2500-2504.

Phosphorus Fertilization for Rice and Control of Environmental Pollution Problems

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2007, 10(13), 2098-2105.

Effect of an Auxin Precursor L-tryptophan on Growth and Yield of Rice (Oryza stiva L.)

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 1998, 1(4), 354-356.

Effect of Seedling Age and Density on Growth and Yield of Rice in Saline Soil

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 1999, 2(3), 860-862.

Niab-Irri-9: A New Salt Tolerant and High Yielding Rice Variety

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 1999, 2(3), 869-870.

Improvement of Nitrogen Fertilizer Efficiency with Nitrification Inhibitors in Lowland Rice

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 1999, 2(4), 1184-1187.

Entomocidal Activity of Bacillus Thuringiensis Transgenic Rice Plants Against Rice Leaffolder, Cnaphalocrocis Medinalis (Lepidoptera: Pyralidae).

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 1999, 2(4), 1472-1477.

Performance of Six Rice Cultivars Under Direct Wet Seeded Conditions of Dera Ismail Khan

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 1999, 2(4), 1504-1506.

Growth and Yield Response of Basmati-385 (Oryza sativa L.) to ZnSO4 Application

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 1999, 2(4), 1632-1633.

Effect of Different Clipping Heights on the Green Fodder, Hay and Seed Production of Four Cultivars of Transplant Aman Rice

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2001, 4(2), 156-158.

Effect of Tree Prunings on Soil Fertility and Crop Yield in Alley Cropping System

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2001, 4(6), 647-650.

Direct Seeded Rice (Dsr) Genotypes for Drought Prone Upland Area

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2001, 4(6), 651-653.

Effect of Agronomic Practices on the Production of Green Fodder, Hay and Seed Yield of Rice

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2001, 4(8), 931-933.

Effect of Pre-flowering Leaf Cutting on Forage and Seed Yield of Transplant Aman Rice

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2001, 4(8), 934-936.

Effect of Nitrogen Rate and Time of Leaf Cutting on Green Fodder as Well as Seed Yield of Rice

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2001, 4(8), 937-939.

Physico-chemical Changes in Different Varieties of Rice as Influenced by the Application of Blue-green Algae

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2001, 4(11), 1306-1311.

Seedling Establishment of an Anoxia-tolerant Rice Genotype as Affected by Soil Source and Days after Submergence

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2001, 4(12), 1495-1497.

Seasonal Effect of Seedling Age on the Yield of Rice

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2002, 5(1), 40-42.

Organic Acids Toxicity on Seedling Attributes of Anoxia Tolerant Rice Genotypes Grown in Hypoxia

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2002, 5(1), 36-39.

Relative Contribution of the Coleoptile and the First Leaf Length to Seedling Establishment of Rice (Oryza sativa L.) as Affected by Anaerobic Seeding in Two Different Soils

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2002, 5(4), 413-415.

Initiation and Cryopreservation of Cell Suspension of Rice Basmati Varieties

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2002, 5(6), 679-682.

Studies on Parental Variability and Heterosis in Rice

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2002, 5(10), 1006-1009.

Effect of NaCl and PEG Induced Osmotic Potentials on Germination and Early Seedling Growth of Rice Cultivars Differing in Salt Tolerance

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2002, 5(11), 1207-1210.

Water Uptake and Germination Pattern of Rice Seeds under Iso-osmotic Solutions of NaCl and Peg, Different Concentrations of CaCl2 and Combinations of NaCl and CaCl2

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2003, 6(12), 1059-1066.

Effect of a Range of Constant Temperatures on Germination of Fifteen Bangladeshi Rice (Oryza sativa L.) Cultivars

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2003, 6(12), 1070-1076.

Inter and Intra-Specific Variation in SDS-PAGE of Total Seed Protein in Rice (Oryza sativa L.) Germplasm

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2004, 7(2), 139-143.

Effect of Salinity on Some Yield Attributes of Rice

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2004, 7(5), 760-762.

Effect of Alternating Saline and Non-saline Conditions on Emergence and Seedling Growth of Rice

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2004, 7(6), 883-890.

Prevalence of Rice Root Nematode in the Farmer Rice Fields as Influenced by Edaphic Factors

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2004, 7(11), 1837-1839.

Population Dynamics of Hirschmanniella oryzae in the Rice Root of Farmer Fields as Affected by Edaphic Factors

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2004, 7(11), 2002-2004.

Yield and Biomass in Rice Interactions of Nitrogen, Phosphorous and Water Application

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2004, 7(12), 2115-2120.

Effect of Water Saving Irrigation on Yield and Concentration of Ca and Mg in Malaysian Rice Cultivation

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2005, 8(1), 65-67.

Accumulation of Cu in Root Apoplasm and Re-translocation to Young Leaves in Rice, Maize and Sunflower with Different Toxicity Tolerance

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2005, 8(11), 1599-1609.

In vitro Plant Regeneration Through Anther Culture of Some Iranian Local Rice (Oryza sativa L.) Cultivars

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2007, 10(12), 2056-2060.

Investigation the Growth, Yield and Yield Components of Rice Varieties in Rotation with Garlic, Faba Bean, Lettuce, Pea and Fallow in North of Iran

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2007, 10(16), 2688-2693.

Effect of Planting Density on Agronomical Characteristics of Rice (Oryza sativa L.) Varieties in North of Iran

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2007, 10(18), 3205-3209.

Effect of Variable Rates of Gypsum Application on Wheat Yield Under Rice-Wheat System

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2007, 10(21), 3865-3869.

Identification of Salt Tolerant Rice Cultivars Via Phenotypic and Marker-Assisted Procedures

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2007, 10(24), 4449-4454.

The Perspective Effects of Various Seed Coating Substances on Rice Seed Variety Khao Dawk Mali 105 Storability II: The Case Study of Chemical and Biochemical Properties

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2009, 12(7), 574-581.

Rice Optimal Water Use in Different Air Temperatures at Flowering, Nitrogen Rates and Plant Populations

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2007, 10(23), 4197-4203.

Genetic Architecture, Inter-relationship and Selection Criteria for Yield Improvement in Rice (Oryza sativa L.)

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2011, 14(9), 540-545.

Performance of Different Rice Cultivars at Farmers` Field under the Agro-climatic Conditions of Dera Ismail Khan

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2003, 6(4), 314-316.

Zinc and Salinity Interaction on Agronomical Traits, Chlorophyll and Proline Content in Lowland Rice (Oryza sativa L.) Genotypes

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2006, 9(7), 1315-1319.

Genetic Evaluation of Recombinant Inbred Lines of Rice (Oryza sativa L.) for Grain Zinc Concentrations, Yield Related Traits and Identification of Associated SSR Markers

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2013, 16(23), 1714-1721.

Pest and Disease Tolerance in Rice cv Pusa Basmati as Related to Different Locally Available Organic Manures Grown in New Alluvail Region of West Bengal, India

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2013, 16(12), 593-597.

Rice Tungro Disease in Sarawak: Past and Present Status

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2015, 18(6), 285-289.

Physio-chemical, Properties, Adoption and Productivity of Some Fine (Basmati) Rice Varieties in Dera Ismail Khan

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 1998, 1(4), 264-266.

Evaluation Of Compost Fertilizer "Zarkhez" In Conjunction With Chemical Fertilizers For Rice And Wheat Production

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 1998, 1(4), 368-371.

Role of Plant Growth Regulators (Auxin and Cytokinin) in Callus Induction in Rice (Oryza sativa L.) C.V. DM-25

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2000, 3(1), 157-159.

Germination and Seedling Growth of Rice (Oryza sativa L.) Under Saline Conditions

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2000, 3(2), 350-351.

Genetic Variability among Different Rice Cultivars for Phosphorus Uptake and Utilization

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2000, 3(5), 881-882.

Genetic Variability among Different Rice Cultivars for Zinc Uptake and Utilization

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2000, 3(7), 1174-1176.

Genetic Variation for Phosphorus Use in Rice at Two Levels of Soil Applied Phosphorus

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2000, 3(8), 1274-1276.

Natural Variation among Rice Yellow Stem Borer, Scirpophaga incertulas (Walker) and Rice Leaffolder, Cnaphalocrocis medinalis (Guenee) Populations to Bacillus thuringiensis δ-endotoxins

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2000, 3(8), 1285-1289.

Screening for Putative Transgenic Rice and Cotton Plants: A Simple and Easy Method

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2000, 3(12), 2226-2228.

Effect of Sodium Chloride Salinity on Seed Germination and Early Seedling Growth of Rice (Oryza sativa L.)

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2001, 4(3), 351-355.

Effect of Tillage Practices and Nitrogen Rates on the Nitrogen Content and Nitrogen Uptake in Rice Var. Binasail

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2003, 6(14), 1202-1204.

Nodulation in Cereals as a Means to Decreasing Their Dependence on Nitrogenous Fertilizers - An Achievable Target or a Dogma

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2002, 5(1), 122-127.

Effect of Seed Cleaning, Washing and Seed Treatment on Seedling Disease Incidence and Yield of Rice

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2002, 5(7), 767-769.

Genetic Diversity in Irrigated Rice

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2004, 7(2), 226-229.

Study of Two Main Approaches-Electrophoresis and Chromatography as Varietal Identification Methods in Rice

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2007, 10(3), 439-445.

Identification and Pathogenicity of Fungal Dieback Disease on Sengon (Paraserianthes falcataria (L.) Nielsen) Seedling and Rice (Oryza sativa)

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2018, 21(1), 16-23.

Control of Rice Powder Pest Sitophilus oryzae L. with Entomopathogenic Fungus Metarhizium anisopliae (Metch.)

Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 2023, 26(2), 56-62.

Cited By


Effect of Some Botanicals on Hemocytes and Molting of Papilio demoleus Larvae

Journal of Entomology, 2012, 9(1), 23. DOI: 10.3923/je.2012.23.31

Evaluation of endod (Phytolacca dodecandra L.) extracts against Botrytis fabae, a causative agent of chocolate spot disease of Vicia faba

Cogent Food & Agriculture, 2019, 5(1), . DOI: 10.1080/23311932.2019.1686948