Comparative Effect of Mineral Fertilizers and Organic Manures on Growth, Nutrient Content and Yield of Chorcorus olitorus and Celosia argentina
S. Olubunmi Makinde,
M. Imisu Usilo,
E. Adeyinka Makinde
L. Samuel Ayeni
Research Journal of Botany,
2011, 6(4), 150-156.
Corchorus olitorus and Celosia argentina are popularly consumed as vegetables in southwestern Nigeria because of their economic and nutritional importance. Therefore, pot experiments were conducted to compare the effect of poultry manure, cow dung, NPK 20:10:10 and urea fertilizers on growth, nutrients content and yield of Corchorus olitorus and Celosia argentina in Lagos southwest Nigeria. The recommended rates of NPK (400 kg ha-1), urea fertilizers (200 kg ha-1) and; poultry manure (10 t ha-1) and cow dung (10 t ha-1) were used as treatments. There was a control without any treatment. The two experiments were separately conducted in year 2010. The treatments were mixed with washed and air dried river sand. Compared with control, all the treatments significantly (p<0.05) increased plant height, number of leaves and dry matter yields of Corchorus olitorus and Celosia argentina. The Corchorus fertilized with NPK had the highest moisture content; poultry manure had the highest nutrient uptake while urea had the highest dry matter yields. Celosia argentina fertilized with poultry manure and cow dung recorded the highest moisture content, nutrient uptake while urea had the highest dry matter yields. The over all yield increase in relation to number of leaves of Corchorus olitorus are in order of NPK> poultry manure>cowdung>urea>control while increases in the leaves of Celosia argentina are in the order of poultry manure>NPK>cow dung>urea>control. Poultry manure, cow dung and NPK fertilizer serve as sources of nutrients for Corchorus and Celosia argentina. Poultry manure where available is better for the production of Corchorus olitorus and Celosia argentina.
Inorganic fertilizers unlike organic fertilizers are usually quick-release
formula making nutrient rapidly available to plants. Inorganic fertilizers are
safe to use. However, because it is quick-releasing salts can build up fast,
damaging soil (soil applications), pumps and airstones used in hydroponics application.
The advantage of using inorganic fertilizers is that nutrients are immediately
available to plants and exact amount of a given element can be measured before
feeding plant (Stolton, 1997).
Inorganic fertilizers do not need certain time to be broken down or decomposed
before usage because they contain nutrient that can be readily absorbed by plants.
Inorganic fertilizers work immediately i.e., they are given as rescue treatment
to plant that is malnourished, unhealthy or even dying. Among inorganic fertilizers,
NPK fertilizer are designed to give plants the three major nutrients; nitrogen
(N), phosphorus (P) and potassium (K) that the plants need in appropriate proportion
and amount (Stolton, 1997). Also, urea fertilizer contains
mainly N (46%). Nitrogen enhances the vegetative growth of plants. This unique
characteristic is good for the vegetable crops that have their leaves, stems
and roots edible. Fresh leaves of Cochorus olitorus are rich source of
vitamin A and C. The small amount of protein present in it is rich in methionine.
The leaves of Corchorus olitorus are used in the treatment of chronic
cystitis, gonorrhea, dysuria, for toothache (Hillocks, 1998).
A cold infusion is used as a tonic to restore the appetite and strength (Sharaf
and Negm, 2005). The leaves have also been found to suppress elevation of
post prandial blood glucose levels in rats and humans (Innami
et al., 2005). The seeds are used for fever and purgative possesses
broad and has antibacterial properties (Pall et al.,
2006). Oils from the seeds are also used for skin diseases. Among the conventional
fertilizers, urea and NPK fertilizers are mostly used to fertilize vegetable
farms in southwestern Nigeria while among the organic manures; poultry and cow
dung are popularly used for vegetable production. Hence, there is need to compare
there effectiveness and usefulness in vegetable production. The objective of
this study was to compare the effect of mineral and organic fertilizers on growth
and yield components of Corchorus olitorus and Celosia argentina
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Source of materials and treatment design: Seeds of Celosia argentena and Cochorus olitorus were collected from Nigeria Institute of Horticulture, Ibadan, Nigeria. The seeds of Celosia argentena and Cochorus olitorus were raised separately in a nursery. At four leaf stage, the seedlings were transplanted into bucket filled with river sand and kept in the screenhouse at the Lagos state university.
Corchorus olitorus: Treatment includes supplementing the soil
with NPK, urea, poultry manure and cow dung. NPK fertilizer was applied the
rate of 2 g/10 kg soil to represent 400 kg ha-1, urea fertilizer
was applied at the rate of 1 g/10 kg soil to represent 200 kg ha-1
while poultry manure and cow dung were each applied at the rate of 50 g/10 kg
soil to give 10 t ha-1 recommended for optimum crop production in
southwest Nigeria. Control experiment enjoyed no treatment (i.e., no application
of either organic or Inorganic nutrient). There were forty pots in all i.e.,
5 treatments replicated eight times. Cow dung and poultry manure were applied
two weeks before Corchorus olitorus seedlings were separately transplanted
into the buckets in order to enhance fast decomposition. NPK 20:10:10 and Urea
fertilizers were separately applied two weeks after transplanting. Equal amount
of water was applied to all the treatments. After 8 weeks of growth, twenty
seedlings were harvested for determination of nutrient uptake growth and yield
components of Corchorus olitorus remaining twenty pots which were used
to determine growth and yield parameters.
Celosia argentina: Twenty buckets were filled with 10 kg of river sand. The same treatments i.e., 400 kg ha-1 NPK20:10:10 fertilizer, 200 kg ha-1 urea fertilizer, 10 t ha-1 of poultry and cow dung were applied as carried out in Corchorus olitorus. Two seedlings per bucket were transplanted to each bucket. The buckets were laid out in Completely Randomized Design with five treatments replicated four times. At 8 weeks after planting, one seedling of Celosia argentina/pot was uprooted for nutrients content determination and dry matter yield leaving the remaining one plant/pot for the determination of growth and yield parameters. The different rates of fertilizers used were based on the recommended rates for optimum production of arable crops especially vegetables in southwestern Nigeria where these experiments were conducted.
Determination of growth and yield parameters of Corchorus olitorus and Celosia argentina: The growth and yield parameters taken were fresh and dried matter of stems, number of nodes on the main stem, plant height, number of branches and leaves. Others were leaf, stem, and root moisture contents. Leaves, stems and roots were harvested, weighed and oven dried at 65°C to constant weight and then reweighed to obtain dry matter yield and moisture contents. Stem girth was determined with the use of vernier calipers.
Analysis of organic manures and plant tissues: The poultry manure and
cow dung used for the experiment were collected, cured for two weeks, ground
with hammer mill and ashed in the muffle furnace. Digestion was carried out
with a mixture of nitric-perchloric-sulphuric acid in order to extract P, K,
Ca and Mg (AOAC, 1991). Total N was digested with sulphuric
acid in the presence of selenium catalyst (Kjedahl catalyst) and distilled before
titration. Available P was determined by Bray-1-method, K and Na by flame photometer.
Calcium and Mg were read on Atomic absorption spectrophotometer. Tissue of Celosia
and Chocorus olitorus were harvested at 5 weeks after planting, oven
dried at 65°C until constant weight was recorded milled and analyzed.
Statistical analysis: Means of the data collected were separated by Least Significant difference.
Analysis of poultry manure and cow dung showed that poultry manure was richer in nutrient concentration than cow dung. Poultry manure was composed of 2.69 N, 1.70 P, 1.72 K, 11.72 Ca, 0.70 Mg and 0.22% Na, respectively while cattle dung was composed of 1.42 N, 1.10 P, 7.20 K, 13.20 Ca, 0.62 Mg and 0.65% Na, respectively.
Corchorus olitorus: Compared with control, application of poultry
manure, cow dung, NPK and urea fertilizers (Table 1) significantly
increased (p>0.05) number of leaves, number of branches (except urea), plant
height and stem girth.
|| Effects of organic and mineral fertilizers on growth parameters
||Effects of organic and mineral fertilizers on moisture contents
and dry matter of Corchorus
||Effects of organic and mineral fertilizers on nutrient composition
of Corchorus olitorus (mg kg-1)
||Effects of organic and mineral fertilizers on growth parameters
NPK fertilizer had the highest number of nodes, number of branches and stem
girth. Urea fertilizer had the highest plant height.
In Table 2, among the treatments, poultry manure recorded the highest leaf moisture. leaf moisture content in Corchorus olitorus increased in the following order Poultry manure>cow dung>NPK fertilizer>urea>control. Poultry manure also had the highest root moisture content the soil samples treated with urea fertilizer had highest leaf, stem and root dry matter yields.
In Table 3 compared with control, all the treatments increased N, P, Ca, Mg, K and Na. poultry manure significantly recorded highest Ca, Mg and K while urea fertilizer had the highest N. NPK fertilizer recorded the highest P.
Celosia argentina: Table 4 shows the growth parameters of Celosia argentina when fertilized with poultry manure, cattle dung, NPK fertilizer and urea fertilizer. Compared with control, all the treatments significantly increased number of nodes, leaves; height and plant girth. The soil samples treated with cow dung had the highest number of nodes, and plant height while the poultry manure had the highest leaves, number of branches and highest girth.
|| Effects of organic and mineral fertilizers on moisture content
and dry matter of Celosia (%)
||Effects of organic and mineral fertilizers on nutrient content
of Celosia (mg kg-1)
Table 5 shows the moisture content of leaf , stem and root; leaf, stem and root dry matter of celosia argentina when poultry manure, cow dung, NPK fertilizer and surea fertilizer were individually applied to Celosia argentina.
Poultry manure had the highest leaf, stem and root moisture contents. Urea fertilizer had the highest increase in leaf, stem and root dry matter contents. Urea also had the highest plat height.
Table 6 show that relative to control experiment, Celosia argentina significantly increased (p>0.05) N, P, K Ca, Mg and Na. celosia grown in the soil samples that contained poultry manure absorbed more P, Ca, Mg, Na and K that all other treatments.
The nutrients composition of poultry manure was higher than cow dung; thus it was expected that poultry manure would release more nutrients to the soil for vegetable uptake than cow dung. The washed river sand used for the experiment was known to be very low in plant nutrients. This would allow the treatments applied to exhibit their chemical properties in releasing nutrients to the soil for plant use.
It was observed that NPK 20:10:10 fertilizer had the highest number of nodes, branches and stem girth while urea fertilizer had the least number of nodes, branches and stem girth in Corchorus olitorus. This might be as a result of N, P and K present in NPK fertilizer. The presence of N in plant tissue is known to increase its vegetative growth and chlorophyll formation for photosynthesis. Phosphorus is known to increase root growth, seed formation and flower development. Potassium aids in osmotic pull of water from the ground and transport to other parts of the plant. Potassium also helps in sugar formation. The very low number of leaves, branches and stem girth recorded by both plants treated with urea fertilizer and control experiment shows the importance of P and K. Urea mainly supplied N with no addition of other nutrients. This shows that crop fertilized with only urea fertilizer would suffer deficiency of other nutrients but would enjoy luxurious consumption of N. This could also be the reason why P, K, Ca, Mg and Na were very low in Corchorus and Celosia fertilized with urea. The river sand that had no treatment was not expected to supply adequate plant nutrient as it would be deficient in plant nutrients; hence low crop yield. The bulk of nutrients absorbed by Corchorus and Celosia in this experiment were likely to come from the treatments applied.
The results showed that Corchorus olitorus and Celosia argentina responded differently to the treatments in relation to growth parameters. NPK fertilizer had the highest agronomic parameters while cow dung and poultry manure had the highest agronomic parameters in Celosia argentina. The difference between the responses of the two vegetables to fertilizers applucation on growth might be a genetic factor as the two vegetables were subjected to the same nutrient and environmental condition.
The vegetables fertilized with urea had the highest plant height and least
stem girth compared with cow dung, poultry manure and NPK fertilizer. The tallness
of the plants might be as a result of high amount of N. Urea fertilizer contains
46% in its formulation. The plants were tall but slender because there was no
Ca to strengthen the plant and K to counteract the negative effect of over dosage
of N in the plants. Plants can only perform well when they enjoy balanced nutrition.
Celosia and Corchorus treated with poultry manure had better yields
because they enjoyed balanced nutrition. Poultry manure and cattle dung contained
N, P, K, Ca, Mg and little amount of trace elements such as Mn, Fe, Cu and Zn
It is argued that organic manures are usually late in nutrient mineralization.
This was the reason why poultry manure and cow dung were cured and applied two
weeks before the planting of Corchorus and Celosia. The major
parts of the nutrient present in poultry manure and cow dung would have mineralized
before the termination of the experiment. Ayeni (2011)
and Ayeni and Adeleye (2011) in the experiments conducted
on the rate of nutrient release by poultry manure showed that larger proportions
of its nutrients were released between one to two months of incubation.
Celosia argentina and Corchorus fertilized with poultry manure, cow dung and NPK fertilizer had higher moisture contents in plants tissues than the vegetables that were fertilized with urea. This might be as result of higher nutrients content especially K in these vegetables. It has earlier been stated that K plays significant role in water transport and plant turgidity. The low moisture in the control experiment might be inability of the plant to absorb adequate water from the soil.
The results from this study conform to similar researches on the effect of
different nutrient sources on the growth and yield of Corchorus and Celosia.
Fawusi (1983) reported increase in the yield and nutritional
value of Corchorus on application of NPK fertilizer. This study also
corroborates with earlier report of Opeyemi and Adegboyega
(2003), who reported that animal manures increased number of leaves, stem
girth, root length, stem and leaf length of Celosia and also leaf N,
P, K, Ca and Mg contents compared to urea. Combination of urea with poultry
manure was also reported to have increased leaf yield (Bobatola
and Oycdummade, 1992) which also conform to the observation recorded from
Pot experiments were carried out to determine the effect of poultry manure, cow dung NPK20:10:10 fertilizer and urea fertilizer on growth and nutrient uptake of Corchorus olitorus and Celosia argentina. The treatments increased the yields and nutrients uptake of the two vegetables. Among the treatments, poultry manure compared favourably with NPK fertilizer in yield parameters. Poultry manure, cow dung and NPK fertilizer serve as sources of nutrients for Corchorus and Celosia argentina. Poultry manure where available is better for the production of Corchorus olitorus and Celosia argentina." class="btn btn-success" target="_blank">View Fulltext
The Growth of Launaea taraxacifolia (Asteraceae) and its Response to Shading
Research Journal of Botany,
2008, 3(2), 90-96.
Soil Chemical Properties and Nutrient Composition of Cocoyam
Grown in an Organically Fertilized Soil
Communications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis,
2019, (), 1.
Okra (Abelsmoschus esculentus L. Moench) performance with the application of composts made from different source materials
Biological Agriculture & Horticulture,
2021, (), 1.